Home / Full timeline / The U.S. Supreme Court, in a six to three decision, rule that a group of seventeen Blacks and two Whites from Cairo, Illinois, could not obtain injunctions against local judges and prosecutors who, the plaintiffs claimed, were engaged in a pattern of setting excessive bail and harsher punishments for Blacks than Whites.
The U.S. Supreme Court, in a six to three decision, rule that a group of seventeen Blacks and two Whites from Cairo, Illinois, could not obtain injunctions against local judges and prosecutors who, the plaintiffs claimed, were engaged in a pattern of setting excessive bail and harsher punishments for Blacks than Whites.
1974 (Jan 15)
The U.S. Supreme Court, in a six to three decision, ruled that a group of seventeen Blacks and two Whites from Cairo, Illinois, could not obtain injunctions against local judges and prosecutors who, the plaintiffs claimed, were engaged in a pattern of setting excessive bail and harsher punishments for Blacks than Whites. The court held that the complaints did not constitute a real case of controversy, hence they did not meet the necessary test for receiving relief from the federal courts. Five members of the six-justice majority also ruled that the plaintiffs would not have been entitled to injunctions even if they had been able to prove discrimination, for such a procedure would be tantamount to “an ongoing audit of state criminal proceedings” in violation of the principle of federalism-federal-state harmony. The majority opinion was supported by Justices Burger, White, Powell, Stewart, Rehnquist, and Blackmun. In a dissent, Justice William O. Douglas said that the record of the case demonstrated “a more pervasive scheme for suppression of Blacks and their civil rights than I have ever seen.” The majority's decision, Douglas added, “will please the White superstructure, but it does violence to the conception of even-handed justice envisioned by the Constitution.” Cairo had been the scene of angry clashes between Blacks and Whites since 1969.
References:
- • Hornsby, Alton. Chronology of African-American History: Significant Events and People from 1619 to the Present. Detroit: Gale Research, 1995.